Buffalo NY Fishing Report – 11/22/2026

by | Nov 22, 2026

Buffalo NY Fishing Report – Observations from 11/16 – 11/22/2026

Here’s our latest Buffalo NY fishing report:  It was a busy week on the water, with a little bit of everything across Lake Erie, the Lower Niagara, and the Lake Ontario Bar. We had some consistent action, a few grindy sessions, personal-best smallies, a four-species day, and even an unexpected introduction to perch fishing. Crowds and changing wind conditions presented a few challenges, but we managed to find fish every day. Lake Erie is finally getting into its fall groove, while the Lower Niagara continues to produce, albeit without the consistency of previous years. Overall, a good week covering a lot of water, fishing with some great people, and making the most of whatever conditions Mother Nature threw our way.

Days on the water: 6

Who we fished with: friends/clients

Where we fished: Lake Erie, Upper Niagara, Lower Niagara, Lake Ontario

What we caught:  smallmouth bass, walleye, lake trout, brown trout

Tactics:  casting finesse baits, drifting live bait and beads, pulling plugs

Detailed Reporting/Daily Observations

 

11/16/2026 – Maintenance Day

The clients on the docket had to reschedule.  I took the day to hit the gym, run errands, and get the annual inspection on my truck. 

11/17/2026 – Lower Niagara and Lake Ontario Bar

Fished the Lower Niagara with Steve, Kevin and Keith.  It was a grindy bite throughout the day, but fish were caught in every zone – only lake trout through.  No pictures desired/taken. 

11/18/2026 – Lake Erie (finally)

Fished Lake Erie out of Buffalo, NY, with new clients Joe and Jon. These guys were in town for a couple of days and wanted the opportunity to see as much as possible in that time.  My kinda people. So, we started with a hunt for tanker small jaws.

There was one other boat out there—that’s it. Waves were 1–3 footers, providing perfect conditions for drifting bait and working finesse baits. It took us a little while to get on fish, but once we found them, the action was consistent. We had a blast building brackets in a couple of zones, with both guys landing personal-best smallies. Great session!

11/19/2026 – Lower Niagara and the Bar to the Upper Niagara   

This was day two with Joe and Jon. The guys wanted to chalk up as many species as possible while fishing the rest of the big water in the Buffalo-Niagara region. The plan was to fish the bar, hit a couple of spots upriver on the Lower Niagara, then move to the Upper Niagara.

Execution went off without issue. Well, we didn’t land a steelhead, but we managed to pick up solid specimens of four species. The only real obstacle was a stiff WSW wind that picked up late morning and made fishing parts of the Upper Niagara challenging. The fish didn’t seem to mind, though, as the bass bite remained consistent.

These guys got the whirlwind tour over a couple of days and loved every minute of it. When folks come in from out of town for a couple of days, I think it’s a disservice—or at least a missed opportunity—to focus on one location and do one thing the entire time. Although the fishing wasn’t on fire everywhere we went, the action was consistent throughout, and the guys have the memories to show for it.

11/20/2026 – Lower Niagara and Lake Ontario Bar

Fished the Lower Niagara with longtime clients Wayne, Nick, and Chad. It was a gorgeous day, so we started on the bar, where the bite was very consistent. With only a handful of boats out there, I opted to stay for a couple of hours and enjoy the action without interference from other boats.

We followed that session with a few upriver zones—what I like to refer to as the “merry-go-rounds.” The bite was good enough to keep things entertaining and anticipation high. We ended the day pursuing smalljaws. Unfortunately, the wind died off, making it difficult to fish the zones I wanted. We caught fish, but Chad landed the only one worth taking a photo of.

11/21/2026 – Lake Erie

Fished Lake Erie with the Whisperer and the Silent Assassin. It was a gorgeous day—and a Saturday—so it was a zoo out there. Everyone with a boat that hadn’t been winterized was on the water, and the calm conditions made fishing tough. We worked through the crowds and put a good number of bass in the boat while there was still a breeze, landing one biggie in the process. Once the wind died, it became grind mode. So, we ditched the crowds and found some, of all things, perch.

I’m not knocking perch fishing—I’ve just never done it. These guys have been nudging me to offer perch charters for years. After giving it a go for an hour or so, I can see the appeal. Maybe it’ll be something I incorporate when conditions are right in 2027.

11/22/2026 – Lower Niagara/Lake Ontario Bar

Fished the Lower Niagara and Lake Ontario Bar with new clients Zach, Dean, and Taylor.  Crowds were surprisingly manageable but an obstacle, nonetheless.  The guys were good anglers and dialed in the presentation quickly.  Unfortunately, it was kind of a grind as only one area produced at a consistent rate.  Good times with some great guys.

Seasonal Assessment/General Observations

I didn’t put a report out last week because I only ended up fishing a couple of days.  I cancelled/rescheduled 5 trips due to weather—mainly N direction winds.  This is as good as any spot to address this: I am brutally transparent with my clients.  In fact, my transparency has a conservative bent to it—meaning I lean toward averting risk of a crappy outing.  When clients REALLY want to fish for trout and nothing else—that’s unfortunate but I guess I get it—you want to catch something big.  Well, when there are N winds, you can only fish for them in a couple of areas.  You can really only ride two merry-go-rounds all day long—sorry—but I don’t have the patience for that.  Especially when there are 40 other boats on the water.  You know what does fish well in a N wind though—Lake Erie—just sayin’.

Anyway, the bite on the Lower Niagara has been, well, OK.  This year’s run of fish is lackluster compared to the previous few years.  Not a dud by any means, but not awesome either.  The run is the run—I don’t think anything is going to change.  Many fish have already dropped eggs.  However, some big pregnant females have shown up recently that make me wonder if more are on the way.  There’s only one way to find out—keep fishing. 

I think as temperatures drop, the bar will fish incredibly well throughout late November and much of December after the bulk of the spawning is over.  There’s a lot of bait out there and with the Niagara churning out unseasonably warm water, more bait will show up.    

Similarly, Lake Erie will continue to get better as temperatures drop.  The fish are finally starting to stack up in their fall zones.  The population is at entertaining levels now—we’re not quite at gangbusters yet.  It’s coming. 

Buffalo NY Fishing Report – Forecast for 11/23/2026 – 11/29/2026

Thanksgiving week should make things interesting. The next few days look very fishable, albeit colder. Maybe that’ll keep some folks inside. If the long-range forecast holds, Thursday and Friday look a little nasty, but the weekend should shape up nicely.

I’m booked daily, with the exception of Thanksgiving. I’ll spend half the days on Lake Erie and the other half on the Lower Niagara.

I hope everyone gets to enjoy the holiday with friends and loved ones.

Stay healthy, my friends.  Mentally and physically,

Ryan